Battle for Blood: Child Custody Conflicts in Divorce – Islamic vs. Customary Law
Child custody disputes following divorce often become complex legal and emotional battles, especially when religious and customary laws intersect. In many Muslim-majority societies, Islamic law (Sharia) and customary law (adat) both influence custody decisions, sometimes complementing each other bu...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Universitas Negeri Semarang
2024-12-01
|
| Series: | Contemporary Issues on Interfaith Law and Society |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://journal.unnes.ac.id/sju/ciils/article/view/79014 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1832572166092095488 |
|---|---|
| author | Destika Santi Putri Sarfitri Ratih Damayanti Rini Fidiyani Winarsih Winarsih Mutmainah Nur Qoiri Jamaluddin Jamal Muhsen |
| author_facet | Destika Santi Putri Sarfitri Ratih Damayanti Rini Fidiyani Winarsih Winarsih Mutmainah Nur Qoiri Jamaluddin Jamal Muhsen |
| author_sort | Destika Santi Putri Sarfitri |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description |
Child custody disputes following divorce often become complex legal and emotional battles, especially when religious and customary laws intersect. In many Muslim-majority societies, Islamic law (Sharia) and customary law (adat) both influence custody decisions, sometimes complementing each other but often conflicting in practice. Islamic law prioritizes the child’s welfare while emphasizing maternal custody during early childhood (hadanah) and paternal guardianship (wilayah) in later years. However, customary law, deeply rooted in local traditions, can override or modify these principles based on community norms, family ties, and social status. This study explores the legal and cultural dimensions of child custody disputes in divorce cases, analyzing the extent to which Islamic law and customary law shape judicial decisions and parental rights. While Islamic law prescribes clear guidelines, its application varies across jurisdictions, influenced by local customs and judicial interpretations. In many cases, customary norms challenge Islamic legal principles, leading to inconsistencies and gendered biases that may disadvantage mothers or overlook the best interests of the child. As globalization and legal reforms push for greater adherence to human rights and child protection standards, the tension between religious and customary laws raises critical questions about the future of custody rulings. This paper examines landmark cases, legal frameworks, and the evolving role of Islamic and customary laws in shaping custody outcomes. By comparing these perspectives, it seeks to highlight the need for harmonized legal solutions that prioritize the child’s well-being while respecting cultural and religious traditions.
|
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-e8d823aaa97e4aee8e9082196dd03267 |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 2829-8373 2829-8624 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2024-12-01 |
| publisher | Universitas Negeri Semarang |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Contemporary Issues on Interfaith Law and Society |
| spelling | doaj-art-e8d823aaa97e4aee8e9082196dd032672025-02-02T11:51:15ZengUniversitas Negeri SemarangContemporary Issues on Interfaith Law and Society2829-83732829-86242024-12-0132Battle for Blood: Child Custody Conflicts in Divorce – Islamic vs. Customary LawDestika Santi Putri Sarfitri0Ratih Damayanti1Rini Fidiyani2Winarsih Winarsih3Mutmainah Nur Qoiri4Jamaluddin Jamal Muhsen5Universitas Negeri SemarangUniversitas Negeri SemarangUniversitas Negeri SemarangUniversitas Negeri SemarangUniversitas Negeri SemarangFatoni University Child custody disputes following divorce often become complex legal and emotional battles, especially when religious and customary laws intersect. In many Muslim-majority societies, Islamic law (Sharia) and customary law (adat) both influence custody decisions, sometimes complementing each other but often conflicting in practice. Islamic law prioritizes the child’s welfare while emphasizing maternal custody during early childhood (hadanah) and paternal guardianship (wilayah) in later years. However, customary law, deeply rooted in local traditions, can override or modify these principles based on community norms, family ties, and social status. This study explores the legal and cultural dimensions of child custody disputes in divorce cases, analyzing the extent to which Islamic law and customary law shape judicial decisions and parental rights. While Islamic law prescribes clear guidelines, its application varies across jurisdictions, influenced by local customs and judicial interpretations. In many cases, customary norms challenge Islamic legal principles, leading to inconsistencies and gendered biases that may disadvantage mothers or overlook the best interests of the child. As globalization and legal reforms push for greater adherence to human rights and child protection standards, the tension between religious and customary laws raises critical questions about the future of custody rulings. This paper examines landmark cases, legal frameworks, and the evolving role of Islamic and customary laws in shaping custody outcomes. By comparing these perspectives, it seeks to highlight the need for harmonized legal solutions that prioritize the child’s well-being while respecting cultural and religious traditions. https://journal.unnes.ac.id/sju/ciils/article/view/79014Child custody, Islamic law, customary law, parental divorce, legal disputes |
| spellingShingle | Destika Santi Putri Sarfitri Ratih Damayanti Rini Fidiyani Winarsih Winarsih Mutmainah Nur Qoiri Jamaluddin Jamal Muhsen Battle for Blood: Child Custody Conflicts in Divorce – Islamic vs. Customary Law Contemporary Issues on Interfaith Law and Society Child custody, Islamic law, customary law, parental divorce, legal disputes |
| title | Battle for Blood: Child Custody Conflicts in Divorce – Islamic vs. Customary Law |
| title_full | Battle for Blood: Child Custody Conflicts in Divorce – Islamic vs. Customary Law |
| title_fullStr | Battle for Blood: Child Custody Conflicts in Divorce – Islamic vs. Customary Law |
| title_full_unstemmed | Battle for Blood: Child Custody Conflicts in Divorce – Islamic vs. Customary Law |
| title_short | Battle for Blood: Child Custody Conflicts in Divorce – Islamic vs. Customary Law |
| title_sort | battle for blood child custody conflicts in divorce islamic vs customary law |
| topic | Child custody, Islamic law, customary law, parental divorce, legal disputes |
| url | https://journal.unnes.ac.id/sju/ciils/article/view/79014 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT destikasantiputrisarfitri battleforbloodchildcustodyconflictsindivorceislamicvscustomarylaw AT ratihdamayanti battleforbloodchildcustodyconflictsindivorceislamicvscustomarylaw AT rinifidiyani battleforbloodchildcustodyconflictsindivorceislamicvscustomarylaw AT winarsihwinarsih battleforbloodchildcustodyconflictsindivorceislamicvscustomarylaw AT mutmainahnurqoiri battleforbloodchildcustodyconflictsindivorceislamicvscustomarylaw AT jamaluddinjamalmuhsen battleforbloodchildcustodyconflictsindivorceislamicvscustomarylaw |