Consensus for Operating Room Multimodal Data Management: Identifying Research Priorities for Data-Driven Surgery
Introduction:. This study aimed to identify research areas that demand attention in multimodal data-driven surgery for improving data management in minimally invasive surgery. Background:. New surgical procedures, high-tech equipment, and digital tools are increasingly being introduced, potentially...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Wolters Kluwer Health
2024-09-01
|
| Series: | Annals of Surgery Open |
| Online Access: | http://journals.lww.com/10.1097/AS9.0000000000000459 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1832589733417451520 |
|---|---|
| author | Alain Garcia Vazquez, MD Juan Verde, MD Ariosto Hernandez Lara, MD Didier Mutter, MD Lee Swanstrom, MD 5G-OR Research Committee, 5G-OR Consensus Panel Ariosto Hernandez Lara Barbara Seeliger Daniel Hashimoto Deepak Alapatt Joel Lavanchy Juan Verde Lise Lecointre Pietro Mascagni Pr.Danail Stoyanov Didier Mutter, MD Dirk Willhelm, MD Pr.Gerald Fried, MD Gretchen Jackson, MD, PhD Jean-Paul Mazellier, PhD Lee Swanstrom, MD Pr.Lena Maier-Hein Pr.Nicolas Padoy, PhD Pr.Sascha Treskatsch, MD Pr.Silvana Perretta, MD, PhD Pr.Stefanie Speidel Pr.Teodor Grantcharov Annika Mareike Engel, BSc, MEng Axel Boese, DrIng Carla M. Pugh, MD, PhD Cesare Hassan Fabian Dietrich, PhD Felix Nickel, MD, MME Franziska Jurosch, MSc Guido Beldi, MD Henriette Hegermann, Dr Johannes Horsch, Dipl-Ing Julian Rosenkranz, Ing, MSc Keno Sponheuer, DrMed Luca Milone, MD, PhD, FACS Nariaki Okamoto, MD, PhD Patrick Seeling, PhD Pedro Filipe Pereira Gouveia, MD, PhD Roland Croner, Prof.Dr Sandra Keller, PhD Sharona B Ross Taiga Wakabayashi, MD, Ph.D Takeaki Ishizawa, MD, PhD Takeshi Urade, MD, PhD Thomas Schnelldorfer, MD, PhD Thorge Lackner, MSc, and MEng |
| author_facet | Alain Garcia Vazquez, MD Juan Verde, MD Ariosto Hernandez Lara, MD Didier Mutter, MD Lee Swanstrom, MD 5G-OR Research Committee, 5G-OR Consensus Panel Ariosto Hernandez Lara Barbara Seeliger Daniel Hashimoto Deepak Alapatt Joel Lavanchy Juan Verde Lise Lecointre Pietro Mascagni Pr.Danail Stoyanov Didier Mutter, MD Dirk Willhelm, MD Pr.Gerald Fried, MD Gretchen Jackson, MD, PhD Jean-Paul Mazellier, PhD Lee Swanstrom, MD Pr.Lena Maier-Hein Pr.Nicolas Padoy, PhD Pr.Sascha Treskatsch, MD Pr.Silvana Perretta, MD, PhD Pr.Stefanie Speidel Pr.Teodor Grantcharov Annika Mareike Engel, BSc, MEng Axel Boese, DrIng Carla M. Pugh, MD, PhD Cesare Hassan Fabian Dietrich, PhD Felix Nickel, MD, MME Franziska Jurosch, MSc Guido Beldi, MD Henriette Hegermann, Dr Johannes Horsch, Dipl-Ing Julian Rosenkranz, Ing, MSc Keno Sponheuer, DrMed Luca Milone, MD, PhD, FACS Nariaki Okamoto, MD, PhD Patrick Seeling, PhD Pedro Filipe Pereira Gouveia, MD, PhD Roland Croner, Prof.Dr Sandra Keller, PhD Sharona B Ross Taiga Wakabayashi, MD, Ph.D Takeaki Ishizawa, MD, PhD Takeshi Urade, MD, PhD Thomas Schnelldorfer, MD, PhD Thorge Lackner, MSc, and MEng |
| author_sort | Alain Garcia Vazquez, MD |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Introduction:. This study aimed to identify research areas that demand attention in multimodal data-driven surgery for improving data management in minimally invasive surgery.
Background:. New surgical procedures, high-tech equipment, and digital tools are increasingly being introduced, potentially benefiting patients and surgical teams. These innovations have resulted in operating rooms evolving into data-rich environments, which, in turn, requires a thorough understanding of the data pipeline for improved and more intelligent real-time data usage. As this new domain is vast, it is necessary to identify where efforts should be focused on developing seamless and practical data usage.
Methods:. A modified electronic Delphi approach was used; 53 investigators were divided into the following groups: a research group (n=9) for problem identification and a narrative literature review, a medical and technical expert group (n=14) for validation, and an invited panel (n=30) for two electronic survey rounds. Round 1 focused on a consensus regarding bottlenecks in surgical data science areas and research gaps, while round 2 prioritized the statements from round 1, and a roadmap was created based on the identified essential and very important research gaps.
Results:. Consensus panelists have identified key research areas, including digitizing operating room (OR) activities, improving data streaming through advanced technologies, uniform protocols for handling multimodal data, and integrating AI for efficiency and safety. The roadmap prioritizes standardizing OR data formats, integrating OR data with patient information, ensuring regulatory compliance, standardizing surgical AI models, and securing data transfers in the next generation of wireless networks.
Conclusions:. This work is an international expert consensus regarding the current issues and key research targets in the promising field of data-driven surgery, highlighting the research needs of many operating room stakeholders with the aim of facilitating the implementation of novel patient care strategies in minimally invasive surgery. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-e1e22d6b79574bfbbd2e46a702b83445 |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 2691-3593 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2024-09-01 |
| publisher | Wolters Kluwer Health |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Annals of Surgery Open |
| spelling | doaj-art-e1e22d6b79574bfbbd2e46a702b834452025-01-24T09:18:48ZengWolters Kluwer HealthAnnals of Surgery Open2691-35932024-09-0153e45910.1097/AS9.0000000000000459202409000-00007Consensus for Operating Room Multimodal Data Management: Identifying Research Priorities for Data-Driven SurgeryAlain Garcia Vazquez, MD0Juan Verde, MD1Ariosto Hernandez Lara, MD2Didier Mutter, MD3Lee Swanstrom, MD45G-OR Research Committee, 5G-OR Consensus PanelAriosto Hernandez LaraBarbara SeeligerDaniel HashimotoDeepak AlapattJoel LavanchyJuan VerdeLise LecointrePietro MascagniPr.Danail StoyanovDidier Mutter, MDDirk Willhelm, MDPr.Gerald Fried, MDGretchen Jackson, MD, PhDJean-Paul Mazellier, PhDLee Swanstrom, MDPr.Lena Maier-HeinPr.Nicolas Padoy, PhDPr.Sascha Treskatsch, MDPr.Silvana Perretta, MD, PhDPr.Stefanie SpeidelPr.Teodor GrantcharovAnnika Mareike Engel, BSc, MEngAxel Boese, DrIngCarla M. Pugh, MD, PhDCesare HassanFabian Dietrich, PhDFelix Nickel, MD, MMEFranziska Jurosch, MScGuido Beldi, MDHenriette Hegermann, DrJohannes Horsch, Dipl-IngJulian Rosenkranz, Ing, MScKeno Sponheuer, DrMedLuca Milone, MD, PhD, FACSNariaki Okamoto, MD, PhDPatrick Seeling, PhDPedro Filipe Pereira Gouveia, MD, PhDRoland Croner, Prof.DrSandra Keller, PhDSharona B RossTaiga Wakabayashi, MD, Ph.DTakeaki Ishizawa, MD, PhDTakeshi Urade, MD, PhDThomas Schnelldorfer, MD, PhDThorge Lackner, MSc, and MEngFrom the * Institute of Image Guided Surgery of Strasbourg, IHU Strasbourg, Strasbourg, FranceFrom the * Institute of Image Guided Surgery of Strasbourg, IHU Strasbourg, Strasbourg, FranceFrom the * Institute of Image Guided Surgery of Strasbourg, IHU Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France† Institute of Image Guided Surgery of Strasbourg, IHU Strasbourg, Hôpitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg and IRCAD Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France.From the * Institute of Image Guided Surgery of Strasbourg, IHU Strasbourg, Strasbourg, FranceIntroduction:. This study aimed to identify research areas that demand attention in multimodal data-driven surgery for improving data management in minimally invasive surgery. Background:. New surgical procedures, high-tech equipment, and digital tools are increasingly being introduced, potentially benefiting patients and surgical teams. These innovations have resulted in operating rooms evolving into data-rich environments, which, in turn, requires a thorough understanding of the data pipeline for improved and more intelligent real-time data usage. As this new domain is vast, it is necessary to identify where efforts should be focused on developing seamless and practical data usage. Methods:. A modified electronic Delphi approach was used; 53 investigators were divided into the following groups: a research group (n=9) for problem identification and a narrative literature review, a medical and technical expert group (n=14) for validation, and an invited panel (n=30) for two electronic survey rounds. Round 1 focused on a consensus regarding bottlenecks in surgical data science areas and research gaps, while round 2 prioritized the statements from round 1, and a roadmap was created based on the identified essential and very important research gaps. Results:. Consensus panelists have identified key research areas, including digitizing operating room (OR) activities, improving data streaming through advanced technologies, uniform protocols for handling multimodal data, and integrating AI for efficiency and safety. The roadmap prioritizes standardizing OR data formats, integrating OR data with patient information, ensuring regulatory compliance, standardizing surgical AI models, and securing data transfers in the next generation of wireless networks. Conclusions:. This work is an international expert consensus regarding the current issues and key research targets in the promising field of data-driven surgery, highlighting the research needs of many operating room stakeholders with the aim of facilitating the implementation of novel patient care strategies in minimally invasive surgery.http://journals.lww.com/10.1097/AS9.0000000000000459 |
| spellingShingle | Alain Garcia Vazquez, MD Juan Verde, MD Ariosto Hernandez Lara, MD Didier Mutter, MD Lee Swanstrom, MD 5G-OR Research Committee, 5G-OR Consensus Panel Ariosto Hernandez Lara Barbara Seeliger Daniel Hashimoto Deepak Alapatt Joel Lavanchy Juan Verde Lise Lecointre Pietro Mascagni Pr.Danail Stoyanov Didier Mutter, MD Dirk Willhelm, MD Pr.Gerald Fried, MD Gretchen Jackson, MD, PhD Jean-Paul Mazellier, PhD Lee Swanstrom, MD Pr.Lena Maier-Hein Pr.Nicolas Padoy, PhD Pr.Sascha Treskatsch, MD Pr.Silvana Perretta, MD, PhD Pr.Stefanie Speidel Pr.Teodor Grantcharov Annika Mareike Engel, BSc, MEng Axel Boese, DrIng Carla M. Pugh, MD, PhD Cesare Hassan Fabian Dietrich, PhD Felix Nickel, MD, MME Franziska Jurosch, MSc Guido Beldi, MD Henriette Hegermann, Dr Johannes Horsch, Dipl-Ing Julian Rosenkranz, Ing, MSc Keno Sponheuer, DrMed Luca Milone, MD, PhD, FACS Nariaki Okamoto, MD, PhD Patrick Seeling, PhD Pedro Filipe Pereira Gouveia, MD, PhD Roland Croner, Prof.Dr Sandra Keller, PhD Sharona B Ross Taiga Wakabayashi, MD, Ph.D Takeaki Ishizawa, MD, PhD Takeshi Urade, MD, PhD Thomas Schnelldorfer, MD, PhD Thorge Lackner, MSc, and MEng Consensus for Operating Room Multimodal Data Management: Identifying Research Priorities for Data-Driven Surgery Annals of Surgery Open |
| title | Consensus for Operating Room Multimodal Data Management: Identifying Research Priorities for Data-Driven Surgery |
| title_full | Consensus for Operating Room Multimodal Data Management: Identifying Research Priorities for Data-Driven Surgery |
| title_fullStr | Consensus for Operating Room Multimodal Data Management: Identifying Research Priorities for Data-Driven Surgery |
| title_full_unstemmed | Consensus for Operating Room Multimodal Data Management: Identifying Research Priorities for Data-Driven Surgery |
| title_short | Consensus for Operating Room Multimodal Data Management: Identifying Research Priorities for Data-Driven Surgery |
| title_sort | consensus for operating room multimodal data management identifying research priorities for data driven surgery |
| url | http://journals.lww.com/10.1097/AS9.0000000000000459 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT alaingarciavazquezmd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT juanverdemd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT ariostohernandezlaramd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT didiermuttermd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT leeswanstrommd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT 5gorresearchcommittee5gorconsensuspanel consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT ariostohernandezlara consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT barbaraseeliger consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT danielhashimoto consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT deepakalapatt consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT joellavanchy consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT juanverde consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT liselecointre consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT pietromascagni consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT prdanailstoyanov consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT didiermuttermd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT dirkwillhelmmd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT prgeraldfriedmd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT gretchenjacksonmdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT jeanpaulmazellierphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT leeswanstrommd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT prlenamaierhein consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT prnicolaspadoyphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT prsaschatreskatschmd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT prsilvanaperrettamdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT prstefaniespeidel consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT prteodorgrantcharov consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT annikamareikeengelbscmeng consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT axelboesedring consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT carlampughmdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT cesarehassan consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT fabiandietrichphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT felixnickelmdmme consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT franziskajuroschmsc consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT guidobeldimd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT henriettehegermanndr consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT johanneshorschdipling consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT julianrosenkranzingmsc consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT kenosponheuerdrmed consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT lucamilonemdphdfacs consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT nariakiokamotomdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT patrickseelingphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT pedrofilipepereiragouveiamdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT rolandcronerprofdr consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT sandrakellerphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT sharonabross consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT taigawakabayashimdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT takeakiishizawamdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT takeshiurademdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT thomasschnelldorfermdphd consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery AT thorgelacknermscandmeng consensusforoperatingroommultimodaldatamanagementidentifyingresearchprioritiesfordatadrivensurgery |