In Praise of Diversity in Participatory Heritage Planning Empowered by Artificial Intelligence: Windcatchers in Yazd
Heritage planning is changing, in both theory and practice. There is greater attention to the cultural significance (values and attributes) conveyed to a heritage property, rather than focusing on the property alone. Identifying and revealing this cultural significance has become a critical step in...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Cogitatio
2025-01-01
|
| Series: | Urban Planning |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.cogitatiopress.com/urbanplanning/article/view/8724 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1832592309296824320 |
|---|---|
| author | Mahda Foroughi Tong Wang Ana Pereira Roders |
| author_facet | Mahda Foroughi Tong Wang Ana Pereira Roders |
| author_sort | Mahda Foroughi |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Heritage planning is changing, in both theory and practice. There is greater attention to the cultural significance (values and attributes) conveyed to a heritage property, rather than focusing on the property alone. Identifying and revealing this cultural significance has become a critical step in heritage planning. Moreover, international guidelines increasingly encourage public participation in defining the cultural significance of heritage sites. However, effectively involving diverse stakeholders and capturing the cultural significance they attribute to heritage remains a challenge, particularly when dealing with extensive datasets and multiple stakeholders. Although automated methods have shown potential in fields like digital humanities, their application in heritage planning is still limited. This article explores the innovative use of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly text classification analysis, to analyze unstructured textual data (e.g., policy documents, literature, and social media) to uncover the cultural significance of built heritage. Focusing on Yazd, Iran, and specifically on windcatchers—a key cultural attribute recognized for its “outstanding universal value” by UNESCO—this study integrates AI to enhance both urban and socio-cultural planning. This article, as the concluding piece of a broader research project, synthesizes the project’s findings to highlight AI’s potential for inclusive heritage planning, referencing related publications of the same project to provide context while remaining concise. The research is structured in three phases: first, a literature review on AI applications in participatory heritage planning and value-based heritage planning; second, the methodology for data collection and analysis, including coding and comparing values and attributes of windcatchers conveyed by different stakeholders; and third, findings on the values and attributes, and their interrelationships as revealed through the data. The results confirm that while there are both conflicts and alignments in the cultural significance attributed to windcatchers in Yazd among various stakeholders, the theoretical framework presented here offers a valuable tool for heritage planning. By decoding and measuring cultural significance from diverse perspectives, this framework aids in identifying conflicts and alignments and in better aligning stakeholder perspectives. This model can be adapted to other key attributes in Yazd and other case studies, offering broader applications in heritage planning. Additionally, the findings underscore the potential of AI to evaluate the legislative framework’s effectiveness in enhancing public engagement. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-beaa7e92b294464a853d575ff6f614f8 |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 2183-7635 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-01-01 |
| publisher | Cogitatio |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Urban Planning |
| spelling | doaj-art-beaa7e92b294464a853d575ff6f614f82025-01-21T10:43:37ZengCogitatioUrban Planning2183-76352025-01-0110010.17645/up.87243965In Praise of Diversity in Participatory Heritage Planning Empowered by Artificial Intelligence: Windcatchers in YazdMahda Foroughi0Tong Wang1Ana Pereira Roders2Department of Architectural Engineering and Technology, Technical University of Delft, The NetherlandsDepartment of Management in the Built Environment, Technical University of Delft, The NetherlandsDepartment of Architectural Engineering and Technology, Technical University of Delft, The NetherlandsHeritage planning is changing, in both theory and practice. There is greater attention to the cultural significance (values and attributes) conveyed to a heritage property, rather than focusing on the property alone. Identifying and revealing this cultural significance has become a critical step in heritage planning. Moreover, international guidelines increasingly encourage public participation in defining the cultural significance of heritage sites. However, effectively involving diverse stakeholders and capturing the cultural significance they attribute to heritage remains a challenge, particularly when dealing with extensive datasets and multiple stakeholders. Although automated methods have shown potential in fields like digital humanities, their application in heritage planning is still limited. This article explores the innovative use of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly text classification analysis, to analyze unstructured textual data (e.g., policy documents, literature, and social media) to uncover the cultural significance of built heritage. Focusing on Yazd, Iran, and specifically on windcatchers—a key cultural attribute recognized for its “outstanding universal value” by UNESCO—this study integrates AI to enhance both urban and socio-cultural planning. This article, as the concluding piece of a broader research project, synthesizes the project’s findings to highlight AI’s potential for inclusive heritage planning, referencing related publications of the same project to provide context while remaining concise. The research is structured in three phases: first, a literature review on AI applications in participatory heritage planning and value-based heritage planning; second, the methodology for data collection and analysis, including coding and comparing values and attributes of windcatchers conveyed by different stakeholders; and third, findings on the values and attributes, and their interrelationships as revealed through the data. The results confirm that while there are both conflicts and alignments in the cultural significance attributed to windcatchers in Yazd among various stakeholders, the theoretical framework presented here offers a valuable tool for heritage planning. By decoding and measuring cultural significance from diverse perspectives, this framework aids in identifying conflicts and alignments and in better aligning stakeholder perspectives. This model can be adapted to other key attributes in Yazd and other case studies, offering broader applications in heritage planning. Additionally, the findings underscore the potential of AI to evaluate the legislative framework’s effectiveness in enhancing public engagement.https://www.cogitatiopress.com/urbanplanning/article/view/8724artificial intelligencecultural heritagecultural significanceiranpublic participationyazd |
| spellingShingle | Mahda Foroughi Tong Wang Ana Pereira Roders In Praise of Diversity in Participatory Heritage Planning Empowered by Artificial Intelligence: Windcatchers in Yazd Urban Planning artificial intelligence cultural heritage cultural significance iran public participation yazd |
| title | In Praise of Diversity in Participatory Heritage Planning Empowered by Artificial Intelligence: Windcatchers in Yazd |
| title_full | In Praise of Diversity in Participatory Heritage Planning Empowered by Artificial Intelligence: Windcatchers in Yazd |
| title_fullStr | In Praise of Diversity in Participatory Heritage Planning Empowered by Artificial Intelligence: Windcatchers in Yazd |
| title_full_unstemmed | In Praise of Diversity in Participatory Heritage Planning Empowered by Artificial Intelligence: Windcatchers in Yazd |
| title_short | In Praise of Diversity in Participatory Heritage Planning Empowered by Artificial Intelligence: Windcatchers in Yazd |
| title_sort | in praise of diversity in participatory heritage planning empowered by artificial intelligence windcatchers in yazd |
| topic | artificial intelligence cultural heritage cultural significance iran public participation yazd |
| url | https://www.cogitatiopress.com/urbanplanning/article/view/8724 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT mahdaforoughi inpraiseofdiversityinparticipatoryheritageplanningempoweredbyartificialintelligencewindcatchersinyazd AT tongwang inpraiseofdiversityinparticipatoryheritageplanningempoweredbyartificialintelligencewindcatchersinyazd AT anapereiraroders inpraiseofdiversityinparticipatoryheritageplanningempoweredbyartificialintelligencewindcatchersinyazd |