Measuring Migration Status Based on the Place of Marriage Overestimates the Share of Male Migrants in Historical Populations. Evidence From Dutch Marriage Certificates

Thanks to the construction of large databases such as LINKS and GENLIAS based on Dutch civil certificates, our knowledge of individual demographic behavior in the past has improved significantly. However, the use of such research infrastructures also introduces some potential pitfalls, as these data...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Matthias Rosenbaum-Feldbrügge, Paul Puschmann
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: International Institute of Social History 2021-03-01
Series:Historical Life Course Studies
Subjects:
Online Access:https://openjournals.nl/index.php/hlcs/article/view/9583
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832574049586249728
author Matthias Rosenbaum-Feldbrügge
Paul Puschmann
author_facet Matthias Rosenbaum-Feldbrügge
Paul Puschmann
author_sort Matthias Rosenbaum-Feldbrügge
collection DOAJ
description Thanks to the construction of large databases such as LINKS and GENLIAS based on Dutch civil certificates, our knowledge of individual demographic behavior in the past has improved significantly. However, the use of such research infrastructures also introduces some potential pitfalls, as these databases do not contain all information available from the original sources. For instance, variables that are available on the original source but lacking in LINKS are the places of residence of the bride and the groom at marriage. A common practice among researchers using LINKS and GENLIAS is therefore to identify migrants by comparing an individual’s birth place with the place of marriage. The place of marriage, however, is not necessarily identical to the place of residence, because couples traditionally contracted their marriage in the bride's or bride's parents' municipality of residence. It is therefore particularly likely that grooms are erroneously considered as migrants even though they had never moved before marriage. In this paper we explore whether this poses a problem to studies using the place of marriage as an equivalent to the place of residence. This will be achieved with the help of the marriage certificates release from the Historical Sample of the Netherlands (HSN), which, unlike LINKS, contains both the place of marriage of the couple and the residence of the bride and groom, and allows us to compare the findings derived from both approaches. The analyses show that identifying migrants based on place of marriage causes indeed a significant overestimation of male migrants, but not of female migrants. We therefore suggest the use of a couple's place of first childbirth as a robustness check to avoid overestimating male migration in the past.
format Article
id doaj-art-94693f4945e843dfb458bc1b79d0c00b
institution Kabale University
issn 2352-6343
language English
publishDate 2021-03-01
publisher International Institute of Social History
record_format Article
series Historical Life Course Studies
spelling doaj-art-94693f4945e843dfb458bc1b79d0c00b2025-02-02T01:20:35ZengInternational Institute of Social HistoryHistorical Life Course Studies2352-63432021-03-011010.51964/hlcs9583Measuring Migration Status Based on the Place of Marriage Overestimates the Share of Male Migrants in Historical Populations. Evidence From Dutch Marriage CertificatesMatthias Rosenbaum-FeldbrüggePaul PuschmannThanks to the construction of large databases such as LINKS and GENLIAS based on Dutch civil certificates, our knowledge of individual demographic behavior in the past has improved significantly. However, the use of such research infrastructures also introduces some potential pitfalls, as these databases do not contain all information available from the original sources. For instance, variables that are available on the original source but lacking in LINKS are the places of residence of the bride and the groom at marriage. A common practice among researchers using LINKS and GENLIAS is therefore to identify migrants by comparing an individual’s birth place with the place of marriage. The place of marriage, however, is not necessarily identical to the place of residence, because couples traditionally contracted their marriage in the bride's or bride's parents' municipality of residence. It is therefore particularly likely that grooms are erroneously considered as migrants even though they had never moved before marriage. In this paper we explore whether this poses a problem to studies using the place of marriage as an equivalent to the place of residence. This will be achieved with the help of the marriage certificates release from the Historical Sample of the Netherlands (HSN), which, unlike LINKS, contains both the place of marriage of the couple and the residence of the bride and groom, and allows us to compare the findings derived from both approaches. The analyses show that identifying migrants based on place of marriage causes indeed a significant overestimation of male migrants, but not of female migrants. We therefore suggest the use of a couple's place of first childbirth as a robustness check to avoid overestimating male migration in the past.https://openjournals.nl/index.php/hlcs/article/view/9583MigrationLINKSHSNMarriage certificatesThe Netherlands
spellingShingle Matthias Rosenbaum-Feldbrügge
Paul Puschmann
Measuring Migration Status Based on the Place of Marriage Overestimates the Share of Male Migrants in Historical Populations. Evidence From Dutch Marriage Certificates
Historical Life Course Studies
Migration
LINKS
HSN
Marriage certificates
The Netherlands
title Measuring Migration Status Based on the Place of Marriage Overestimates the Share of Male Migrants in Historical Populations. Evidence From Dutch Marriage Certificates
title_full Measuring Migration Status Based on the Place of Marriage Overestimates the Share of Male Migrants in Historical Populations. Evidence From Dutch Marriage Certificates
title_fullStr Measuring Migration Status Based on the Place of Marriage Overestimates the Share of Male Migrants in Historical Populations. Evidence From Dutch Marriage Certificates
title_full_unstemmed Measuring Migration Status Based on the Place of Marriage Overestimates the Share of Male Migrants in Historical Populations. Evidence From Dutch Marriage Certificates
title_short Measuring Migration Status Based on the Place of Marriage Overestimates the Share of Male Migrants in Historical Populations. Evidence From Dutch Marriage Certificates
title_sort measuring migration status based on the place of marriage overestimates the share of male migrants in historical populations evidence from dutch marriage certificates
topic Migration
LINKS
HSN
Marriage certificates
The Netherlands
url https://openjournals.nl/index.php/hlcs/article/view/9583
work_keys_str_mv AT matthiasrosenbaumfeldbrugge measuringmigrationstatusbasedontheplaceofmarriageoverestimatestheshareofmalemigrantsinhistoricalpopulationsevidencefromdutchmarriagecertificates
AT paulpuschmann measuringmigrationstatusbasedontheplaceofmarriageoverestimatestheshareofmalemigrantsinhistoricalpopulationsevidencefromdutchmarriagecertificates