Optimizing Neurobehavioral Assessment for Patients with Disorders of Consciousness: Proposal of a Comprehensive Pre-Assessment Checklist for Clinicians
Background: Clinicians are challenged by the ambiguity and uncertainty in assessing level of consciousness in individuals with disorder of consciousness (DoC). There are numerous challenges to valid and reliable neurobehavioral assessment and classification of DoC due to multiple environmental and p...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
MDPI AG
2025-01-01
|
| Series: | Brain Sciences |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3425/15/1/71 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1832588913136369664 |
|---|---|
| author | Kristen Keech Caroline Schnakers Brooke Murtaugh Katherine O’Brien Beth Slomine Marie-Michèle Briand Rita Formisano Aurore Thibaut Anna Estraneo Enrique Noé Olivia Gosseries Liliana da Conceição Teixeira |
| author_facet | Kristen Keech Caroline Schnakers Brooke Murtaugh Katherine O’Brien Beth Slomine Marie-Michèle Briand Rita Formisano Aurore Thibaut Anna Estraneo Enrique Noé Olivia Gosseries Liliana da Conceição Teixeira |
| author_sort | Kristen Keech |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Background: Clinicians are challenged by the ambiguity and uncertainty in assessing level of consciousness in individuals with disorder of consciousness (DoC). There are numerous challenges to valid and reliable neurobehavioral assessment and classification of DoC due to multiple environmental and patient-related biases including behavioral fluctuation and confounding or co-occurring medical conditions. Addressing these biases could impact accuracy of assessment and is an important aspect of the DoC assessment process. Methods: A pre-assessment checklist was developed by a group of interdisciplinary DoC clinical experts and researchers based on the existing literature, current validated tools, and expert opinions. Once finalized, the checklist was electronically distributed to clinicians with a range of experience in neurobehavioral assessment with DoC. Respondents were asked to use the checklist prior to completing a neurobehavioral assessment. A survey was also provided to respondents to obtain feedback regarding checklist feasibility and utility in optimizing the behavioral assessments. Results: Thirty-three clinicians completed the survey after using the checklist. Over half of the respondents were a combination of physicians, neuropsychologists, and physical therapists. All respondents served the adult DoC population and 42% percent had over ten years of clinical experience. Eighty percent reported they found the format of the checklist useful and easy to use. All respondents reported the checklist was relevant to preparing for behavioral assessment in the DoC population. Eighty-four percent reported they would recommend the use of the tool to other clinicians. Conclusions: The use of a pre-assessment checklist was found to be feasible and efficacious in increasing interdisciplinary clinician’s ability to optimize the patient and environment in preparation for neurobehavioral assessment. Initial results of clinicians’ perception of the utility of a pre-assessment checklist were positive. However, further validation of the tool is needed with larger sample sizes to improve representation of clinical use across disciplines and care settings. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-871ba84de01f4ee9a75ba59faa33511a |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 2076-3425 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-01-01 |
| publisher | MDPI AG |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Brain Sciences |
| spelling | doaj-art-871ba84de01f4ee9a75ba59faa33511a2025-01-24T13:25:53ZengMDPI AGBrain Sciences2076-34252025-01-011517110.3390/brainsci15010071Optimizing Neurobehavioral Assessment for Patients with Disorders of Consciousness: Proposal of a Comprehensive Pre-Assessment Checklist for CliniciansKristen Keech0Caroline Schnakers1Brooke Murtaugh2Katherine O’Brien3Beth Slomine4Marie-Michèle Briand5Rita Formisano6Aurore Thibaut7Anna Estraneo8Enrique Noé9Olivia Gosseries10Liliana da Conceição Teixeira11The Queen’s Medical Center, Honolulu, HI 96813, USAResearch Institute, Casa Colina Hospital and Centers for Healthcare, Pomona, CA 91767, USADepartment of Rehabilitation Programs, Madonna Rehabilitation Hospitals, Lincoln, NE 68506, USATIRR Memorial Hermann, Houston, TX 77030, USABrain Injury Clinical Research Center, Kennedy Krieger Institute, Baltimore, MD 21205, USAPhysical Medicine and Rehabilitation Department, Hôpital du Sacré-Coeur de Montréal, Montreal, QC H4J 1C5, CanadaIRCCS Santa Lucia Foundation, 00179 Rome, ItalyComa Science Group, GIGA-Consciousness, University of Liège, 4000 Liège, BelgiumIRCCS, Don Gnocchi Foundation, 50143 Florence, ItalyIRENEA Instituto de Rehabilitación Neurológica, Fundación Hospitales Vithas, 46011 Valencia, SpainComa Science Group, GIGA-Consciousness, University of Liège, 4000 Liège, BelgiumRISE-Health, Center for Translational Health and Medical Biotechnology Research (TBIO), ESS, Polytechnic of Porto, R. Dr. António Bernardino de Almeida, 400, 4200-072 Porto, PortugalBackground: Clinicians are challenged by the ambiguity and uncertainty in assessing level of consciousness in individuals with disorder of consciousness (DoC). There are numerous challenges to valid and reliable neurobehavioral assessment and classification of DoC due to multiple environmental and patient-related biases including behavioral fluctuation and confounding or co-occurring medical conditions. Addressing these biases could impact accuracy of assessment and is an important aspect of the DoC assessment process. Methods: A pre-assessment checklist was developed by a group of interdisciplinary DoC clinical experts and researchers based on the existing literature, current validated tools, and expert opinions. Once finalized, the checklist was electronically distributed to clinicians with a range of experience in neurobehavioral assessment with DoC. Respondents were asked to use the checklist prior to completing a neurobehavioral assessment. A survey was also provided to respondents to obtain feedback regarding checklist feasibility and utility in optimizing the behavioral assessments. Results: Thirty-three clinicians completed the survey after using the checklist. Over half of the respondents were a combination of physicians, neuropsychologists, and physical therapists. All respondents served the adult DoC population and 42% percent had over ten years of clinical experience. Eighty percent reported they found the format of the checklist useful and easy to use. All respondents reported the checklist was relevant to preparing for behavioral assessment in the DoC population. Eighty-four percent reported they would recommend the use of the tool to other clinicians. Conclusions: The use of a pre-assessment checklist was found to be feasible and efficacious in increasing interdisciplinary clinician’s ability to optimize the patient and environment in preparation for neurobehavioral assessment. Initial results of clinicians’ perception of the utility of a pre-assessment checklist were positive. However, further validation of the tool is needed with larger sample sizes to improve representation of clinical use across disciplines and care settings.https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3425/15/1/71assessmentdisorders of consciousnessbrain injurysurvey |
| spellingShingle | Kristen Keech Caroline Schnakers Brooke Murtaugh Katherine O’Brien Beth Slomine Marie-Michèle Briand Rita Formisano Aurore Thibaut Anna Estraneo Enrique Noé Olivia Gosseries Liliana da Conceição Teixeira Optimizing Neurobehavioral Assessment for Patients with Disorders of Consciousness: Proposal of a Comprehensive Pre-Assessment Checklist for Clinicians Brain Sciences assessment disorders of consciousness brain injury survey |
| title | Optimizing Neurobehavioral Assessment for Patients with Disorders of Consciousness: Proposal of a Comprehensive Pre-Assessment Checklist for Clinicians |
| title_full | Optimizing Neurobehavioral Assessment for Patients with Disorders of Consciousness: Proposal of a Comprehensive Pre-Assessment Checklist for Clinicians |
| title_fullStr | Optimizing Neurobehavioral Assessment for Patients with Disorders of Consciousness: Proposal of a Comprehensive Pre-Assessment Checklist for Clinicians |
| title_full_unstemmed | Optimizing Neurobehavioral Assessment for Patients with Disorders of Consciousness: Proposal of a Comprehensive Pre-Assessment Checklist for Clinicians |
| title_short | Optimizing Neurobehavioral Assessment for Patients with Disorders of Consciousness: Proposal of a Comprehensive Pre-Assessment Checklist for Clinicians |
| title_sort | optimizing neurobehavioral assessment for patients with disorders of consciousness proposal of a comprehensive pre assessment checklist for clinicians |
| topic | assessment disorders of consciousness brain injury survey |
| url | https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3425/15/1/71 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT kristenkeech optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT carolineschnakers optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT brookemurtaugh optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT katherineobrien optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT bethslomine optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT mariemichelebriand optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT ritaformisano optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT aurorethibaut optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT annaestraneo optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT enriquenoe optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT oliviagosseries optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians AT lilianadaconceicaoteixeira optimizingneurobehavioralassessmentforpatientswithdisordersofconsciousnessproposalofacomprehensivepreassessmentchecklistforclinicians |