“’Tis a reckless Debowch of a Game”: Chance and Resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s Novels
This paper seeks to consider games — and more particularly card games and gambling — as an American form of resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s novels. As opposed to agôn, a category of games that Roger Caillois delineates in Man, Play and Games (1958) as “a combat in which equality of chances is artific...
Saved in:
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
SAES
2020-11-01
|
| Series: | Angles |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://journals.openedition.org/angles/2672 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1849735842720907264 |
|---|---|
| author | Bastien Meresse |
| author_facet | Bastien Meresse |
| author_sort | Bastien Meresse |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | This paper seeks to consider games — and more particularly card games and gambling — as an American form of resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s novels. As opposed to agôn, a category of games that Roger Caillois delineates in Man, Play and Games (1958) as “a combat in which equality of chances is artificially created, in order that the adversaries should confront each other under ideal conditions,” alea encompasses games of chance which are “a strict negation of controlled effort, […] efficacious resort to skill, power, and calculation, and self-control; respect for the rules; the desire to test oneself under conditions of equality.” It will be my contention that alea, in Pynchon’s novels, offers the possibility of an alternative world and becomes a necessary mode of resistance in the face of a plenty-flushed adversity which threatens to hold sway over the American continent. For Pynchon’s players, more often than not cheaters and fraudsters, use such games of chance to fulfil their longing for emancipation and flight, at a time in history when the American continent is about to be mapped by the abstractions of colonial companies and Enlightenment science. Gaming clubs — ranging from taverns in Mason & Dixon to casinos and gambling dens in Gravity’s Rainbow (1973), Against the Day (2006), and Inherent Vice (2009) — can be recognized as heterotopian sites where otherwise dispersed groups of people momentarily gather in order to gain freedom from the ruling few. Although the moralism of Puritan ministers sternly reminded their flocks to refrain from wasting their earnings on rash bets, gambling can thus be envisioned as a way to escape from the hyper-productivity expounded by modernity, intersecting with Walter Benjamin’s discourse on the materialist form of gambling within industrial capitalism. Following Gerda Reith’s and Susan Strange’s arguments in The Age of Chance (1999) and Casino Capitalism (1986), I will further argue that, in the new capitalist economy, Pynchon anticipates in his novels the attention of late capitalism to new areas for capitalization, overseeing both the commodification of idleness and the insinuation into the fabric of existence of the same risk assessment strategy as that applied by capitalism. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-7b9cc8459f6c4bfabd51e664ddd6d226 |
| institution | DOAJ |
| issn | 2274-2042 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2020-11-01 |
| publisher | SAES |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Angles |
| spelling | doaj-art-7b9cc8459f6c4bfabd51e664ddd6d2262025-08-20T03:07:27ZengSAESAngles2274-20422020-11-011110.4000/angles.2672“’Tis a reckless Debowch of a Game”: Chance and Resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s NovelsBastien MeresseThis paper seeks to consider games — and more particularly card games and gambling — as an American form of resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s novels. As opposed to agôn, a category of games that Roger Caillois delineates in Man, Play and Games (1958) as “a combat in which equality of chances is artificially created, in order that the adversaries should confront each other under ideal conditions,” alea encompasses games of chance which are “a strict negation of controlled effort, […] efficacious resort to skill, power, and calculation, and self-control; respect for the rules; the desire to test oneself under conditions of equality.” It will be my contention that alea, in Pynchon’s novels, offers the possibility of an alternative world and becomes a necessary mode of resistance in the face of a plenty-flushed adversity which threatens to hold sway over the American continent. For Pynchon’s players, more often than not cheaters and fraudsters, use such games of chance to fulfil their longing for emancipation and flight, at a time in history when the American continent is about to be mapped by the abstractions of colonial companies and Enlightenment science. Gaming clubs — ranging from taverns in Mason & Dixon to casinos and gambling dens in Gravity’s Rainbow (1973), Against the Day (2006), and Inherent Vice (2009) — can be recognized as heterotopian sites where otherwise dispersed groups of people momentarily gather in order to gain freedom from the ruling few. Although the moralism of Puritan ministers sternly reminded their flocks to refrain from wasting their earnings on rash bets, gambling can thus be envisioned as a way to escape from the hyper-productivity expounded by modernity, intersecting with Walter Benjamin’s discourse on the materialist form of gambling within industrial capitalism. Following Gerda Reith’s and Susan Strange’s arguments in The Age of Chance (1999) and Casino Capitalism (1986), I will further argue that, in the new capitalist economy, Pynchon anticipates in his novels the attention of late capitalism to new areas for capitalization, overseeing both the commodification of idleness and the insinuation into the fabric of existence of the same risk assessment strategy as that applied by capitalism.https://journals.openedition.org/angles/2672capitalismAmerican literaturePynchon Thomasgambling |
| spellingShingle | Bastien Meresse “’Tis a reckless Debowch of a Game”: Chance and Resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s Novels Angles capitalism American literature Pynchon Thomas gambling |
| title | “’Tis a reckless Debowch of a Game”: Chance and Resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s Novels |
| title_full | “’Tis a reckless Debowch of a Game”: Chance and Resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s Novels |
| title_fullStr | “’Tis a reckless Debowch of a Game”: Chance and Resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s Novels |
| title_full_unstemmed | “’Tis a reckless Debowch of a Game”: Chance and Resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s Novels |
| title_short | “’Tis a reckless Debowch of a Game”: Chance and Resistance in Thomas Pynchon’s Novels |
| title_sort | tis a reckless debowch of a game chance and resistance in thomas pynchon s novels |
| topic | capitalism American literature Pynchon Thomas gambling |
| url | https://journals.openedition.org/angles/2672 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT bastienmeresse tisarecklessdebowchofagamechanceandresistanceinthomaspynchonsnovels |