The Neural Impact of a Brief Mindfulness and Improvisational Singing Practice on Music Performance Anxiety
Music Performance Anxiety (MPA) negatively impacts musicians’ personal lives, professional functioning, and performance quality, and is most prevalent in young adulthood. This mixed methods study investigated whether two weeks of a novel intervention called Environmental Vocal Exploration (EVE; Odd...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
GAMUT - Grieg Academy Music Therapy Research Centre (NORCE & University of Bergen)
2025-03-01
|
| Series: | Voices |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://voices.no/index.php/voices/article/view/4210 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850284824430903296 |
|---|---|
| author | Angela Boland Kayla Boileau Nicola Oddy Laurie-Ann Welch Nicole Stanson Gilles Comeau Andra Smith |
| author_facet | Angela Boland Kayla Boileau Nicola Oddy Laurie-Ann Welch Nicole Stanson Gilles Comeau Andra Smith |
| author_sort | Angela Boland |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description |
Music Performance Anxiety (MPA) negatively impacts musicians’ personal lives, professional functioning, and performance quality, and is most prevalent in young adulthood. This mixed methods study investigated whether two weeks of a novel intervention called Environmental Vocal Exploration (EVE; Oddy, 2022), combining mindfulness and vocal improvisation, could alter neural activity associated with MPA in young musicians. The EVE intervention was compared with 1) a traditional two-week mindfulness program and 2) no intervention. Pre- and post-intervention, 27 musicians aged 18–28 (n = 7: EVE, n = 10: mindfulness,
n = 10: no intervention) completed an anxietyprovoking task and a letter N-back working memory task during fMRI. A thematic analysis was also conducted on discussion transcripts from EVE sessions. During the anxietyprovoking task, blood flow in emotional processing and attention-related brain areas (e.g., limbic and salience network areas) increased from pre- to post-EVE, consistent with themes (e.g., present-moment awareness). During the post-intervention N-back, EVE participants showed less activity than the other groups in cognitive processing areas (e.g., middle cingulate gyrus), indicating enhanced neural efficiency. Both interventions may impact neural activation linked to MPA, through increased attentional and emotional regulation. Vocal improvisation in a mindfulness intervention seemed to augment such effects. Results support further study of EVE’s use for MPA.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge the Brain Imaging Centre, including Rahim Ismaili, Katie Dinelle, and Reggie Taylor, for their support.
|
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-73da7d6a77de47e88ea81d59c49d30e8 |
| institution | OA Journals |
| issn | 1504-1611 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-03-01 |
| publisher | GAMUT - Grieg Academy Music Therapy Research Centre (NORCE & University of Bergen) |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Voices |
| spelling | doaj-art-73da7d6a77de47e88ea81d59c49d30e82025-08-20T01:47:28ZengGAMUT - Grieg Academy Music Therapy Research Centre (NORCE & University of Bergen)Voices1504-16112025-03-0125110.15845/voices.v25i1.4210The Neural Impact of a Brief Mindfulness and Improvisational Singing Practice on Music Performance AnxietyAngela Boland0Kayla Boileau1Nicola Oddy2Laurie-Ann Welch3Nicole Stanson4Gilles Comeau5Andra Smith6University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada Carleton University, Ottawa, CanadaUniversity of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada Music Performance Anxiety (MPA) negatively impacts musicians’ personal lives, professional functioning, and performance quality, and is most prevalent in young adulthood. This mixed methods study investigated whether two weeks of a novel intervention called Environmental Vocal Exploration (EVE; Oddy, 2022), combining mindfulness and vocal improvisation, could alter neural activity associated with MPA in young musicians. The EVE intervention was compared with 1) a traditional two-week mindfulness program and 2) no intervention. Pre- and post-intervention, 27 musicians aged 18–28 (n = 7: EVE, n = 10: mindfulness, n = 10: no intervention) completed an anxietyprovoking task and a letter N-back working memory task during fMRI. A thematic analysis was also conducted on discussion transcripts from EVE sessions. During the anxietyprovoking task, blood flow in emotional processing and attention-related brain areas (e.g., limbic and salience network areas) increased from pre- to post-EVE, consistent with themes (e.g., present-moment awareness). During the post-intervention N-back, EVE participants showed less activity than the other groups in cognitive processing areas (e.g., middle cingulate gyrus), indicating enhanced neural efficiency. Both interventions may impact neural activation linked to MPA, through increased attentional and emotional regulation. Vocal improvisation in a mindfulness intervention seemed to augment such effects. Results support further study of EVE’s use for MPA. Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the Brain Imaging Centre, including Rahim Ismaili, Katie Dinelle, and Reggie Taylor, for their support. https://voices.no/index.php/voices/article/view/4210mindfulnessmusic performance anxietyneuroimagingenvironmental vocal explorationsinging |
| spellingShingle | Angela Boland Kayla Boileau Nicola Oddy Laurie-Ann Welch Nicole Stanson Gilles Comeau Andra Smith The Neural Impact of a Brief Mindfulness and Improvisational Singing Practice on Music Performance Anxiety Voices mindfulness music performance anxiety neuroimaging environmental vocal exploration singing |
| title | The Neural Impact of a Brief Mindfulness and Improvisational Singing Practice on Music Performance Anxiety |
| title_full | The Neural Impact of a Brief Mindfulness and Improvisational Singing Practice on Music Performance Anxiety |
| title_fullStr | The Neural Impact of a Brief Mindfulness and Improvisational Singing Practice on Music Performance Anxiety |
| title_full_unstemmed | The Neural Impact of a Brief Mindfulness and Improvisational Singing Practice on Music Performance Anxiety |
| title_short | The Neural Impact of a Brief Mindfulness and Improvisational Singing Practice on Music Performance Anxiety |
| title_sort | neural impact of a brief mindfulness and improvisational singing practice on music performance anxiety |
| topic | mindfulness music performance anxiety neuroimaging environmental vocal exploration singing |
| url | https://voices.no/index.php/voices/article/view/4210 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT angelaboland theneuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT kaylaboileau theneuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT nicolaoddy theneuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT laurieannwelch theneuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT nicolestanson theneuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT gillescomeau theneuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT andrasmith theneuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT angelaboland neuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT kaylaboileau neuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT nicolaoddy neuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT laurieannwelch neuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT nicolestanson neuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT gillescomeau neuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety AT andrasmith neuralimpactofabriefmindfulnessandimprovisationalsingingpracticeonmusicperformanceanxiety |