An exploration of desired abstinent and non-abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamine
Abstract Background In the United States, complete abstinence persists as the standard for demonstrating recovery success from substance use disorders (SUDs), apart from alcohol use disorder (AUD). Although the FDA has recently indicated openness for non-abstinence outcomes as treatment targets, the...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
BMC
2025-01-01
|
| Series: | Harm Reduction Journal |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1186/s12954-025-01155-6 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1832594903042883584 |
|---|---|
| author | Alex Elswick Amanda Fallin-Bennett Karen L. Roper Evan Batty Christopher J. McLouth William Stoops Hilary L. Surratt Carrie B. Oser |
| author_facet | Alex Elswick Amanda Fallin-Bennett Karen L. Roper Evan Batty Christopher J. McLouth William Stoops Hilary L. Surratt Carrie B. Oser |
| author_sort | Alex Elswick |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Background In the United States, complete abstinence persists as the standard for demonstrating recovery success from substance use disorders (SUDs), apart from alcohol use disorder (AUD). Although the FDA has recently indicated openness for non-abstinence outcomes as treatment targets, the traditional benchmark of complete abstinence for new medications to treat SUDs remains a hurdle and overshadows other non-abstinent outcomes desired by people with SUDs (e.g., improved sleep, employment, family reunification). This study sought to expand the definition of recovery to include non-abstinent pathways by exploring non-abstinence-based outcomes desired by people who use methamphetamine (PWUM). Methods Participants (n = 100) were recruited from existing National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) projects including a treatment-seeking sample of people recently released from prison (all of whom endorsed recent methamphetamine use) and a sample of people using syringe service programs. In a convergent survey design, participants responded to closed-ended questions regarding recovery outcomes, followed by open-ended items to gain a better understanding of PWUM and their conception of recovery. The importance of non-abstinent outcomes was measured in five categories (substance use, physical health, cognitive functioning, mental health, and financial/social/relationships). Results Participants were primarily White (88%), male (67%), and an average age of 40. Approximately two-thirds of participants agreed that people need to stop all mood- or mind-altering substances to be in recovery (64%). Nevertheless, participants indicated a variety of desired non-abstinent recovery outcomes, both substance-related (e.g. reductions in methamphetamine use) and non-substance-related (e.g. improved economic stability). Specific non-abstinent outcomes endorsed as “absolutely essential” by PWUM included: preventing legal trouble (92%), employment stability (82%), improved quality of life (80%), housing stability (78%), improved coping skills (78%), improved relationships (75%), economic/income stability (74%), ability to think clearly (73%), less impulsivity (73%), less depression (71%), less stress (70%), improved hopefulness (70%), and improved sleep (70%). Open-ended responses emphasized employment stability, economic/income stability, improved coping skills, improved relationships, as well as improved energy, appetite, and sleep. Conclusion Our findings indicate the importance of non-abstinent recovery outcomes among PWUM, suggesting high acceptability of non-abstinent recovery targets by people with lived experience. Further, the essential importance of non-abstinent outcomes, especially in the financial/social/relationship and mental health domains, were highlighted, providing novel targets for delivering SUD treatment/recovery. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-6039e25bbcee4e28abf76b3dd779040f |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 1477-7517 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-01-01 |
| publisher | BMC |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Harm Reduction Journal |
| spelling | doaj-art-6039e25bbcee4e28abf76b3dd779040f2025-01-19T12:16:04ZengBMCHarm Reduction Journal1477-75172025-01-0122111010.1186/s12954-025-01155-6An exploration of desired abstinent and non-abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamineAlex Elswick0Amanda Fallin-Bennett1Karen L. Roper2Evan Batty3Christopher J. McLouth4William Stoops5Hilary L. Surratt6Carrie B. Oser7University of KentuckyUniversity of KentuckyUniversity of KentuckyUniversity of KentuckyUniversity of KentuckyUniversity of KentuckyUniversity of KentuckyUniversity of KentuckyAbstract Background In the United States, complete abstinence persists as the standard for demonstrating recovery success from substance use disorders (SUDs), apart from alcohol use disorder (AUD). Although the FDA has recently indicated openness for non-abstinence outcomes as treatment targets, the traditional benchmark of complete abstinence for new medications to treat SUDs remains a hurdle and overshadows other non-abstinent outcomes desired by people with SUDs (e.g., improved sleep, employment, family reunification). This study sought to expand the definition of recovery to include non-abstinent pathways by exploring non-abstinence-based outcomes desired by people who use methamphetamine (PWUM). Methods Participants (n = 100) were recruited from existing National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) projects including a treatment-seeking sample of people recently released from prison (all of whom endorsed recent methamphetamine use) and a sample of people using syringe service programs. In a convergent survey design, participants responded to closed-ended questions regarding recovery outcomes, followed by open-ended items to gain a better understanding of PWUM and their conception of recovery. The importance of non-abstinent outcomes was measured in five categories (substance use, physical health, cognitive functioning, mental health, and financial/social/relationships). Results Participants were primarily White (88%), male (67%), and an average age of 40. Approximately two-thirds of participants agreed that people need to stop all mood- or mind-altering substances to be in recovery (64%). Nevertheless, participants indicated a variety of desired non-abstinent recovery outcomes, both substance-related (e.g. reductions in methamphetamine use) and non-substance-related (e.g. improved economic stability). Specific non-abstinent outcomes endorsed as “absolutely essential” by PWUM included: preventing legal trouble (92%), employment stability (82%), improved quality of life (80%), housing stability (78%), improved coping skills (78%), improved relationships (75%), economic/income stability (74%), ability to think clearly (73%), less impulsivity (73%), less depression (71%), less stress (70%), improved hopefulness (70%), and improved sleep (70%). Open-ended responses emphasized employment stability, economic/income stability, improved coping skills, improved relationships, as well as improved energy, appetite, and sleep. Conclusion Our findings indicate the importance of non-abstinent recovery outcomes among PWUM, suggesting high acceptability of non-abstinent recovery targets by people with lived experience. Further, the essential importance of non-abstinent outcomes, especially in the financial/social/relationship and mental health domains, were highlighted, providing novel targets for delivering SUD treatment/recovery.https://doi.org/10.1186/s12954-025-01155-6 |
| spellingShingle | Alex Elswick Amanda Fallin-Bennett Karen L. Roper Evan Batty Christopher J. McLouth William Stoops Hilary L. Surratt Carrie B. Oser An exploration of desired abstinent and non-abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamine Harm Reduction Journal |
| title | An exploration of desired abstinent and non-abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamine |
| title_full | An exploration of desired abstinent and non-abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamine |
| title_fullStr | An exploration of desired abstinent and non-abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamine |
| title_full_unstemmed | An exploration of desired abstinent and non-abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamine |
| title_short | An exploration of desired abstinent and non-abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamine |
| title_sort | exploration of desired abstinent and non abstinent recovery outcomes among people who use methamphetamine |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1186/s12954-025-01155-6 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT alexelswick anexplorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT amandafallinbennett anexplorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT karenlroper anexplorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT evanbatty anexplorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT christopherjmclouth anexplorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT williamstoops anexplorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT hilarylsurratt anexplorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT carrieboser anexplorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT alexelswick explorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT amandafallinbennett explorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT karenlroper explorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT evanbatty explorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT christopherjmclouth explorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT williamstoops explorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT hilarylsurratt explorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine AT carrieboser explorationofdesiredabstinentandnonabstinentrecoveryoutcomesamongpeoplewhousemethamphetamine |