Application of the Healthy Eating Index in a multicultural population: introduction of Adaptive Component Scoring

The United States, and many modern nations, represent assemblies of many cultural groups. Such groups are often influenced, sometimes profoundly, by the culinary traditions of their countries of origin, resulting in a diversity of cultural dietary patterns. Such patterns all derive key elements of n...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: David L. Katz, Lauren Q. Rhee, Dina L. Aronson
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Frontiers Media S.A. 2025-02-01
Series:Frontiers in Nutrition
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnut.2025.1511230/full
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832540319477923840
author David L. Katz
Lauren Q. Rhee
Dina L. Aronson
author_facet David L. Katz
Lauren Q. Rhee
Dina L. Aronson
author_sort David L. Katz
collection DOAJ
description The United States, and many modern nations, represent assemblies of many cultural groups. Such groups are often influenced, sometimes profoundly, by the culinary traditions of their countries of origin, resulting in a diversity of cultural dietary patterns. Such patterns all derive key elements of nutritional quality from essential food groups—such as vegetables and fruits—but vary in their inclusion of “discretionary” food groups, such as dairy. The application of robust, validated, and standardized diet quality scoring is important in nutrition research, and in the food-as-medicine movement at large if what is being “managed” is to be measured. While robustly validated, the Healthy Eating Index is closely aligned with the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, and thus may not readily account for all multicultural dietary variations. Other diet quality metrics account for deviation from the prevailing American dietary pattern, but none does so in a way that expressly adapts to food components included or excluded so that “credit” for nutritional quality is appropriately assigned in all cases using a standard metric. In this context, we introduce and explain Adaptive Component Scoring as applied to the Healthy Eating Index in the service of advancing fair and universal diet quality scoring. Implications for nutrition research and food-as-medicine initiatives are briefly enumerated.
format Article
id doaj-art-56a9c0c9cc6649f283d6db4ca3cc28d5
institution Kabale University
issn 2296-861X
language English
publishDate 2025-02-01
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format Article
series Frontiers in Nutrition
spelling doaj-art-56a9c0c9cc6649f283d6db4ca3cc28d52025-02-05T05:17:54ZengFrontiers Media S.A.Frontiers in Nutrition2296-861X2025-02-011210.3389/fnut.2025.15112301511230Application of the Healthy Eating Index in a multicultural population: introduction of Adaptive Component ScoringDavid L. KatzLauren Q. RheeDina L. AronsonThe United States, and many modern nations, represent assemblies of many cultural groups. Such groups are often influenced, sometimes profoundly, by the culinary traditions of their countries of origin, resulting in a diversity of cultural dietary patterns. Such patterns all derive key elements of nutritional quality from essential food groups—such as vegetables and fruits—but vary in their inclusion of “discretionary” food groups, such as dairy. The application of robust, validated, and standardized diet quality scoring is important in nutrition research, and in the food-as-medicine movement at large if what is being “managed” is to be measured. While robustly validated, the Healthy Eating Index is closely aligned with the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, and thus may not readily account for all multicultural dietary variations. Other diet quality metrics account for deviation from the prevailing American dietary pattern, but none does so in a way that expressly adapts to food components included or excluded so that “credit” for nutritional quality is appropriately assigned in all cases using a standard metric. In this context, we introduce and explain Adaptive Component Scoring as applied to the Healthy Eating Index in the service of advancing fair and universal diet quality scoring. Implications for nutrition research and food-as-medicine initiatives are briefly enumerated.https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnut.2025.1511230/fulldiet qualitydietary indexdiet scoreHealthy Eating Indexdietary patternsmulticultural diets
spellingShingle David L. Katz
Lauren Q. Rhee
Dina L. Aronson
Application of the Healthy Eating Index in a multicultural population: introduction of Adaptive Component Scoring
Frontiers in Nutrition
diet quality
dietary index
diet score
Healthy Eating Index
dietary patterns
multicultural diets
title Application of the Healthy Eating Index in a multicultural population: introduction of Adaptive Component Scoring
title_full Application of the Healthy Eating Index in a multicultural population: introduction of Adaptive Component Scoring
title_fullStr Application of the Healthy Eating Index in a multicultural population: introduction of Adaptive Component Scoring
title_full_unstemmed Application of the Healthy Eating Index in a multicultural population: introduction of Adaptive Component Scoring
title_short Application of the Healthy Eating Index in a multicultural population: introduction of Adaptive Component Scoring
title_sort application of the healthy eating index in a multicultural population introduction of adaptive component scoring
topic diet quality
dietary index
diet score
Healthy Eating Index
dietary patterns
multicultural diets
url https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnut.2025.1511230/full
work_keys_str_mv AT davidlkatz applicationofthehealthyeatingindexinamulticulturalpopulationintroductionofadaptivecomponentscoring
AT laurenqrhee applicationofthehealthyeatingindexinamulticulturalpopulationintroductionofadaptivecomponentscoring
AT dinalaronson applicationofthehealthyeatingindexinamulticulturalpopulationintroductionofadaptivecomponentscoring