Pornography and Speech Act Theory – An In-Depth Survey

Considering the short history of the feminist philosophy of language, Rae Langton’s article “Speech Acts and Unspeakable Acts” was highly influential as one of the first positive research programs in the movement. In her paper, Langton – using John L. Austin’s speech act theory – interprets Cathari...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Áron Dombrovszki
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Eötvös Loránd University 2021-04-01
Series:Elpis
Subjects:
Online Access:https://ojs.elte.hu/elpis/article/view/7602
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832586402077868032
author Áron Dombrovszki
author_facet Áron Dombrovszki
author_sort Áron Dombrovszki
collection DOAJ
description Considering the short history of the feminist philosophy of language, Rae Langton’s article “Speech Acts and Unspeakable Acts” was highly influential as one of the first positive research programs in the movement. In her paper, Langton – using John L. Austin’s speech act theory – interprets Catharine MacKinnon’s thesis: pornography is a speech that subordinates and silences women. Despite the importance of the subject, those unfamiliar with certain historical and contextual features of the topic would hardly understand it. My paper aims to introduce some of the major accounts in this special area at the intersection of speech act theory and feminist philosophy. Rather than just reconstructing Langton’s arguments and the most common objections against it, I take a more holistic approach, examining its surrounding literature as well. My article has six sections. In Section 1, I contrast the conservative and liberal arguments against pornography and sketch MacKinnon’s liberal critique. In Section 2, I give alternative interpretations of MacKinnon’s thesis that “pornography is harm.” In Section 3, I try to make sense of the prima facie implausible assumption that pornography is speech. In Section 4 and 5, I analyze the Langtonian theories about subordination and silencing. Finally, in Section 6, I mention the most challenging problems for Langton’s approach, considering the verbal nature of pornography, the limits of the protection of free speech, and the different positions on sexual consent.
format Article
id doaj-art-3c78760c76df4ca18da72a6c17ec561f
institution Kabale University
issn 1788-8298
2732-3684
language English
publishDate 2021-04-01
publisher Eötvös Loránd University
record_format Article
series Elpis
spelling doaj-art-3c78760c76df4ca18da72a6c17ec561f2025-01-25T17:58:07ZengEötvös Loránd UniversityElpis1788-82982732-36842021-04-0114110.54310/Elpis.2021.1.27309Pornography and Speech Act Theory – An In-Depth SurveyÁron Dombrovszki0ELTE BTK Considering the short history of the feminist philosophy of language, Rae Langton’s article “Speech Acts and Unspeakable Acts” was highly influential as one of the first positive research programs in the movement. In her paper, Langton – using John L. Austin’s speech act theory – interprets Catharine MacKinnon’s thesis: pornography is a speech that subordinates and silences women. Despite the importance of the subject, those unfamiliar with certain historical and contextual features of the topic would hardly understand it. My paper aims to introduce some of the major accounts in this special area at the intersection of speech act theory and feminist philosophy. Rather than just reconstructing Langton’s arguments and the most common objections against it, I take a more holistic approach, examining its surrounding literature as well. My article has six sections. In Section 1, I contrast the conservative and liberal arguments against pornography and sketch MacKinnon’s liberal critique. In Section 2, I give alternative interpretations of MacKinnon’s thesis that “pornography is harm.” In Section 3, I try to make sense of the prima facie implausible assumption that pornography is speech. In Section 4 and 5, I analyze the Langtonian theories about subordination and silencing. Finally, in Section 6, I mention the most challenging problems for Langton’s approach, considering the verbal nature of pornography, the limits of the protection of free speech, and the different positions on sexual consent. https://ojs.elte.hu/elpis/article/view/7602Analytic PhilosophyFeminist Philosophy of LanguagePornographySpeech Act TheorySilencing
spellingShingle Áron Dombrovszki
Pornography and Speech Act Theory – An In-Depth Survey
Elpis
Analytic Philosophy
Feminist Philosophy of Language
Pornography
Speech Act Theory
Silencing
title Pornography and Speech Act Theory – An In-Depth Survey
title_full Pornography and Speech Act Theory – An In-Depth Survey
title_fullStr Pornography and Speech Act Theory – An In-Depth Survey
title_full_unstemmed Pornography and Speech Act Theory – An In-Depth Survey
title_short Pornography and Speech Act Theory – An In-Depth Survey
title_sort pornography and speech act theory an in depth survey
topic Analytic Philosophy
Feminist Philosophy of Language
Pornography
Speech Act Theory
Silencing
url https://ojs.elte.hu/elpis/article/view/7602
work_keys_str_mv AT arondombrovszki pornographyandspeechacttheoryanindepthsurvey