Differential between-therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depression
Psychotherapists can differ in their effectiveness. Yet, more research is needed to determine the generalizability of between-therapist effects to cultures beyond the US and UK, and whether these effects differ by treatment context. Addressing these gaps, we examined therapist effects in a randomize...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Taylor & Francis Group
2024-12-01
|
| Series: | Cogent Mental Health |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/10.1080/28324765.2024.2379248 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1832583458487009280 |
|---|---|
| author | Anuj H. P. Mehta Michael J. Constantino Jack J. M. Dekker Alice E. Coyne Averi N. Gaines Henricus L. Van Jaap Peen Frank J. Don Ellen Driessen |
| author_facet | Anuj H. P. Mehta Michael J. Constantino Jack J. M. Dekker Alice E. Coyne Averi N. Gaines Henricus L. Van Jaap Peen Frank J. Don Ellen Driessen |
| author_sort | Anuj H. P. Mehta |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Psychotherapists can differ in their effectiveness. Yet, more research is needed to determine the generalizability of between-therapist effects to cultures beyond the US and UK, and whether these effects differ by treatment context. Addressing these gaps, we examined therapist effects in a randomized trial comparing cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) versus psychodynamic therapy (PDT) for depression in the Netherlands, hypothesizing that therapists would explain significant outcome variance across both treatments. We also explored whether the size of therapist effects differed by degree of treatment standardization; in this trial, CBT was structured and manualized, whereas PDT was flexible and principle driven. Patients were 254 adults who received 16 sessions of CBT or PDT from 59 therapists nested within the condition. As predicted, multilevel models revealed significant therapist effects (explaining 3–8% of variance) on patient depression and general distress outcomes. Moreover, PDT therapists (10–16%) accounted for more outcome variance than CBT therapists (2–6%), though differences were only statistically significant for the clinician-rated depression outcome. Results extend the cultural “reach” of therapist effects. Moreover, they highlight treatment standardization as one possible determinant of effectiveness differences, which necessitates determining for which therapists such standardization is most important for optimizing their patient’s outcomes. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-297caf151325453db18adc1656e44660 |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 2832-4765 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2024-12-01 |
| publisher | Taylor & Francis Group |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Cogent Mental Health |
| spelling | doaj-art-297caf151325453db18adc1656e446602025-01-28T13:18:19ZengTaylor & Francis GroupCogent Mental Health2832-47652024-12-013111910.1080/28324765.2024.2379248Differential between-therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depressionAnuj H. P. Mehta0Michael J. Constantino1Jack J. M. Dekker2Alice E. Coyne3Averi N. Gaines4Henricus L. Van5Jaap Peen6Frank J. Don7Ellen Driessen8Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, University of Massachusetts Amherst, Amherst, MA, USADepartment of Psychological and Brain Sciences, University of Massachusetts Amherst, Amherst, MA, USAFaculty of Behavioural and Movement Sciences, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The NetherlandsDepartment of Psychology, American University, Washington, DC, USADepartment of Psychological and Brain Sciences, University of Massachusetts Amherst, Amherst, MA, USAArkin Mental Health Care, Amsterdam, The NetherlandsArkin Mental Health Care, Amsterdam, The NetherlandsDepression Expertise Center, Pro Persona Mental Health Care, Nijmegen, The NetherlandsDepression Expertise Center, Pro Persona Mental Health Care, Nijmegen, The NetherlandsPsychotherapists can differ in their effectiveness. Yet, more research is needed to determine the generalizability of between-therapist effects to cultures beyond the US and UK, and whether these effects differ by treatment context. Addressing these gaps, we examined therapist effects in a randomized trial comparing cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) versus psychodynamic therapy (PDT) for depression in the Netherlands, hypothesizing that therapists would explain significant outcome variance across both treatments. We also explored whether the size of therapist effects differed by degree of treatment standardization; in this trial, CBT was structured and manualized, whereas PDT was flexible and principle driven. Patients were 254 adults who received 16 sessions of CBT or PDT from 59 therapists nested within the condition. As predicted, multilevel models revealed significant therapist effects (explaining 3–8% of variance) on patient depression and general distress outcomes. Moreover, PDT therapists (10–16%) accounted for more outcome variance than CBT therapists (2–6%), though differences were only statistically significant for the clinician-rated depression outcome. Results extend the cultural “reach” of therapist effects. Moreover, they highlight treatment standardization as one possible determinant of effectiveness differences, which necessitates determining for which therapists such standardization is most important for optimizing their patient’s outcomes.https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/10.1080/28324765.2024.2379248therapist effectstreatment standardizationcognitive behavioral therapypsychodynamic therapydepression |
| spellingShingle | Anuj H. P. Mehta Michael J. Constantino Jack J. M. Dekker Alice E. Coyne Averi N. Gaines Henricus L. Van Jaap Peen Frank J. Don Ellen Driessen Differential between-therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depression Cogent Mental Health therapist effects treatment standardization cognitive behavioral therapy psychodynamic therapy depression |
| title | Differential between-therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depression |
| title_full | Differential between-therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depression |
| title_fullStr | Differential between-therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depression |
| title_full_unstemmed | Differential between-therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depression |
| title_short | Differential between-therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depression |
| title_sort | differential between therapist effects in more versus less standardized therapies for depression |
| topic | therapist effects treatment standardization cognitive behavioral therapy psychodynamic therapy depression |
| url | https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/10.1080/28324765.2024.2379248 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT anujhpmehta differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression AT michaeljconstantino differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression AT jackjmdekker differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression AT aliceecoyne differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression AT averingaines differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression AT henricuslvan differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression AT jaappeen differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression AT frankjdon differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression AT ellendriessen differentialbetweentherapisteffectsinmoreversuslessstandardizedtherapiesfordepression |