Oscar, Derrida’s Cat, and Other Knowing Animals

Man is a knowing animal. Knowledge is his distinctive mark. Yet in confrontations with animals, particularly in circumstances involving death, human knowledge suddenly appears limited. Other forms of knowledge have to be taken into account. The case of Oscar, the cat who predicts patients’ death in...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Wendy Harding, Jacky Martin
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Association Française d'Etudes Américaines 2012-06-01
Series:Transatlantica
Subjects:
Online Access:https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/5627
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832580665488441344
author Wendy Harding
Jacky Martin
author_facet Wendy Harding
Jacky Martin
author_sort Wendy Harding
collection DOAJ
description Man is a knowing animal. Knowledge is his distinctive mark. Yet in confrontations with animals, particularly in circumstances involving death, human knowledge suddenly appears limited. Other forms of knowledge have to be taken into account. The case of Oscar, the cat who predicts patients’ death in a Rhode Island hospital, indicates that animals know things that are concealed from us. Our knowledge is limited, a premise that Derrida analyses in The Animal that Therefore I Am, where he admits that the philosophical literature about animals does not satisfactorily justify his human difference. Barry Lopez shows that our knowledge is not only insufficient when it comes to accounting for the agony of a school of beached whales, but that it is a poor substitute for our perplexity in the face of death. Heidegger’s analysis in Being and Time offers an affirmative conception of the confrontation with death. Death ceases to be the destabilizing nothingness that threatens our existence and instead provokes knowledge. The study of two correlated texts, by Dickey and Dillard helps nuance the heroic Heideggerian conception of death. Finally, Loren Eiseley hints at a possibility that only literature can afford. Instead of attempting to seize the world through culture or envying animals’ authenticity, human beings can acquire tangential perspectives upon their world and that of animals.
format Article
id doaj-art-0df4df4d80914ca09e553a0afccf458c
institution Kabale University
issn 1765-2766
language English
publishDate 2012-06-01
publisher Association Française d'Etudes Américaines
record_format Article
series Transatlantica
spelling doaj-art-0df4df4d80914ca09e553a0afccf458c2025-01-30T10:45:04ZengAssociation Française d'Etudes AméricainesTransatlantica1765-27662012-06-01210.4000/transatlantica.5627Oscar, Derrida’s Cat, and Other Knowing AnimalsWendy HardingJacky MartinMan is a knowing animal. Knowledge is his distinctive mark. Yet in confrontations with animals, particularly in circumstances involving death, human knowledge suddenly appears limited. Other forms of knowledge have to be taken into account. The case of Oscar, the cat who predicts patients’ death in a Rhode Island hospital, indicates that animals know things that are concealed from us. Our knowledge is limited, a premise that Derrida analyses in The Animal that Therefore I Am, where he admits that the philosophical literature about animals does not satisfactorily justify his human difference. Barry Lopez shows that our knowledge is not only insufficient when it comes to accounting for the agony of a school of beached whales, but that it is a poor substitute for our perplexity in the face of death. Heidegger’s analysis in Being and Time offers an affirmative conception of the confrontation with death. Death ceases to be the destabilizing nothingness that threatens our existence and instead provokes knowledge. The study of two correlated texts, by Dickey and Dillard helps nuance the heroic Heideggerian conception of death. Finally, Loren Eiseley hints at a possibility that only literature can afford. Instead of attempting to seize the world through culture or envying animals’ authenticity, human beings can acquire tangential perspectives upon their world and that of animals.https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/5627deathAnimalbecoming-animalJaques DerridaJames DickeyAnnie Dillard
spellingShingle Wendy Harding
Jacky Martin
Oscar, Derrida’s Cat, and Other Knowing Animals
Transatlantica
death
Animal
becoming-animal
Jaques Derrida
James Dickey
Annie Dillard
title Oscar, Derrida’s Cat, and Other Knowing Animals
title_full Oscar, Derrida’s Cat, and Other Knowing Animals
title_fullStr Oscar, Derrida’s Cat, and Other Knowing Animals
title_full_unstemmed Oscar, Derrida’s Cat, and Other Knowing Animals
title_short Oscar, Derrida’s Cat, and Other Knowing Animals
title_sort oscar derrida s cat and other knowing animals
topic death
Animal
becoming-animal
Jaques Derrida
James Dickey
Annie Dillard
url https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/5627
work_keys_str_mv AT wendyharding oscarderridascatandotherknowinganimals
AT jackymartin oscarderridascatandotherknowinganimals